Underdog BBQ

Overall worth the price for a unique dining experience. The pickle appetizer was huge! The fries are fresh cut and delicious! The BBQ sauces are homemade like and unique- they had a peach one, pickle, jerk flavor, etc. although I just preferred the traditional, a brown sugar cinnamon or mesquite style bbq and also a Carolina bbq is always a staple that was missing tho. The pulled pork sandwich on a pretzel Bun was better than the burger. It was a big portion, nice big chunk pork. However they were good. The burger was on bread and it was disappointing cause the bread was soaked/soggy. But overall still good.

This place is disgusting. It took 20 minutes to get a beer in a can. A glass was not offered. The waitress was completely not interested in providing me any kind of service. The beef soup was good. I got it 40 minutes later. But only after I asked if I might get some food tonight. 1 hr later some over cooked, extremely dry brisket. It Was meant for the trash. The chicken was also gross. I think they dug it out of the trash. O l ft

I haven't been to Underdog since they moved to a new location and hired a new pitmaster, but they're doing everything right. We got the smoked deviled eggs and WOW they were great, every flavor shines through but go so well together. Then we shared the mini gauntlet: brisket, ribs, chicken, pulled pork, baked beans, we subbed sweet potato fries for the Mac and cheese, and of course slaw. Great smoke on the brisket, ribs were uniquely seasoned and the marriage of those with the apple BBQ sauce is made in heaven. The star of the show somehow was the chicken! 10/10 no notes! Can't wait to go back again!

Spectacular experience! Everything was delicious and prepared with care, and the service was amazing! Matt made excellent recommendations and the chef timed everything perfectly! We started with the Smokey Devils, followed by Smoked Wings dry rubbed with Rust Belt. Next was the Backyard BBQ Brisket Platter and Fresh Cut Fries. Last we devoured the Billionaire's Mac which was the most delicious version of mac that has ever macced! Shells & cheese topped with burnt ends, whiskey onions, bacon, gouda panko, and s We ended with delightful banana pudding! Everything we ordered was so impressive, and the six sauces were all so good- we drove in from Pittsburgh and can't wait to come back!

The food was great overall. Deviled eggs were an awesome appetizer! The chilli was good, the meatloaf was great and the brisket was one of the best, if not the best I've ever had. Mashed potatoes were flavorful and unique. The shells and cheese were okay, I was expecting a smoked flavor from a BBQ place. It was my first time being there but always been on my list to go since watching the show when it originally aired!